{"service":"corpus","corpus":"gutenberg","source":"Project Gutenberg","license":"Public domain (per item)","record":{"id":"79853","title":"Romance in science","text":"The Project Gutenberg eBook of Romance in science\n    \nThis eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and\nmost other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions\nwhatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms\nof the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online\nat www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,\nyou will have to check the laws of the country where you are located\nbefore using this eBook.\n\nTitle: Romance in science\n        Lectures from a course called \"Browse\"\n\nAuthor: Bessie Irving Miller\n\n\n        \nRelease date: October 24, 2026 [eBook #79853]\n\nLanguage: English\n\nOriginal publication: Boston: The Stratford Company, 1924\n\nOther information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/79853\n\nCredits: Vicki Parnell, Fay Dunn, Laura Natal and the Online Distributed Proofreading Team at https://www.pgdp.net (This book was produced from images made available by the HathiTrust Digital Library.)\n\n\n*** START OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK ROMANCE IN SCIENCE ***\n\n[Illustration]\n\n\n\n\n                               ROMANCE IN\n                                SCIENCE\n\n                     Lectures from a course called\n                                “Browse”\n\n                                  _by_\n\n                          BESSIE IRVING MILLER\n                             A. B., Ph. D.\n\n              Professor of Mathematics in Rockford College\n\n                             [Illustration]\n\n                                  1924\n                    THE STRATFORD CO., _Publishers_\n                         BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS\n\n\n\n\n                            Copyright, 1924\n                     The STRATFORD CO., Publishers\n                             Boston, Mass.\n\n\n               The Alpine Press, Boston, Mass., U. S. A.\n\n\n\n\n                             TO MY FRIENDS\n\n                          ANNIE DAVISSON KELLY\n\n                A painter of the exquisite out-of-doors\n                                  and\n\n                        GRACE ELIZABETH BENJAMIN\n\n                          A scholarly student,\n                 through whose efforts the publication\n                    of this book was made possible.\n\n\n\n\n                                Preface\n\n\nTHE SERIES of lectures collected under the title “Browse” have no\noriginal contribution to make to the subject of Mathematics. The debt\nto Pearson, Schlick, Poincaré, Keyser, Korzybski, and others is obvious\nto the most casual reader. The author has, however, for many years\ncultivated the study of Mathematics without any real hope of ever\nhaving the opportunity of using it professionally. Frequently a friend\nhas asked her if she thought her study profitable from the personal\npoint of view. Her reply was always in the affirmative. It is in the\nspirit of that college girl who found in Mathematics work and play,\nsupport and inspiration, that these lectures were delivered to college\ngirls, some of whom do not even elect the subject in college after the\nfreshman year. These lectures are but invitations to other students to\nwalk in a pleasant meadow along paths which are always beautiful and\nwhich at times disclose unexpected vistas of glorious ideals.\n\n                                                   BESSIE IRVING MILLER.\n\nRockford College, 1923.\n\n\n\n\n                   Preface to the First Typed Edition\n\n\nIT IS with real pleasure that I at this time express my appreciation\nof the work of those through whose efforts these lectures have been\ngiven permanent form. “Browse” is a series of lectures which are the\noutgrowth of occasional lectures, talks, discussions, questions, and\nessays, the need of which grows more and more apparent to those of us\nwho are interested in teaching mathematics rather than in teaching a\ntext. It is at the request and expense of the members of the course\nthat the lectures have been typed. In particular, Miss Bohnmilla\nHrdlicka, a former student, has done much of the reading aloud and the\ncollecting of collateral material. Miss Wilma Anderson has attended\nto the business details, and Miss Grace Benjamin has not only given\nmuch time and energy to the taking of notes in class but has also\ncontributed much of her own marked literary ability in editing and\narranging the lectures so as to preserve something of the vividness\nwith which I speak but cannot write. It is therefore to my students\nthat I express my thanks.\n\n\n\n\n          Members of Mathematics XVIII, called “Browse,” 1923.\n\n\n  W. ANDERSON\n  G. BENJAMIN\n  L. BROWN\n  L. CHRISTENSEN\n  M. ECKBURG\n  G. FERRY\n  M. HAYES\n  G. HOTELLING\n  A. MCFADYEN\n  M. MITCHELL\n  O. NASH\n  M. WILLIAMS\n  L. M. CHURCH\n  J. HERRICK\n\n                                                                B. I. M.\n\nMay 27, 1923.\n\n\n\n\n                           Table of Contents\n\n\n                                                     Page\n\n Browse                                                 1\n\n The Scientific Method                                  5\n\n Law                                                   13\n\n The Fourth Dimension                                  23\n\n The Fourth Dimension and Non-Euclidean\n Geometry                                              34\n\n Einstein’s Theory of Gravitation                      39\n\n Transformations                                       52\n\n “The Human Significance of Mathematics”               64\n\n Appendix                                              75\n\n\n\n\n                                 Browse\n\n              (In which duty is guaranteed to be omitted.)\n\n\n_Browse_ has several titles. It was first named _Mathematics\nXVIII_, and under this number appeared in the catalogue. The\ndescription given it bore the double heading: _“The Romance of\nScience” or “The Grammar of Science,” According to Which You Wish to\nGet Out of It._ Officially it is now known as _Some Literature of\nScience_. But in the registrar’s office it has always been known as\n_Browse_.\n\nThe first title and the last are perhaps the most descriptive. Under\nthe first a history and description of the course was presented to\na not altogether frivolous body of mathematicians in their meeting,\nof May, 1922, at Rockford College, in conjunction with the Illinois\nAcademy of Science. Although the last title of the course may seem\nfrivolous, the course itself was distinctly not of the dime-novel\nvariety. Some literature of science constitutes its subject matter, and\nboth in content and in treatment it is decidedly scientific.\n\nBut where comes the likeness between science and romance, you ask?\nThe likenesses are both many and excellent. A spirit of adventure, the\nwillingness to depart from the beaten path, is absolutely necessary to\nboth. In each my advice is: go until you are completely lost. It is\na glorious sensation. Test it for yourselves, and determine whether\nthere is any romance like unto the romance of going forward into the\nintellectually unknown. There is, however, one caution to be observed.\nRemember that you must go straight forward, for a circle in thinking,\nlike a circle in Mathematics, is a completely closed curve.\n\nBut it is _Browse_ which best describes the method of study\nadvised in the course. Have you ever seen a sleek, biscuit-colored\nJersey cow, hock-deep in the lush grass of a meadow where it slopes\ndown toward a transparent stream tinkling over brown stones in the\nshadow of large weeping-willow trees? It is a Jersey cow which browses.\nA Jersey does not crop continuously, as do the startlingly black and\nwhite Holsteins in their short-grass pastures. A Jersey crops only now\nand then, and between times gazes meditatively over the landscape.\n\n_Browse_ is a beautiful road through a country of phenomenal\nrichness. At times we shall come to a shady lane, too inviting to\nbe neglected. At such times we shall gaze about us, eschewing the\nthree-mile gate which limits others to a glance at only the most\noutstanding beauties about them.\n\nThe lanes which are to entice us must necessarily be subject in\nvariety to certain restrictions imposed by my own environment and\nby the college equipment. In the first place I am limited by what\nI have studied or read in the past. My references to Mathematics,\nAstronomy, Architecture, Physics, Biology, English, Literature, and\nPhilosophy must therefore be more frequent, exact, and interesting\nthan my references to Geology, Chemistry, and Music. This is the\nresult, not of taste, but of training. Again, there is the practical\nconsideration--our library. The books which other departments than my\nown have ordered in the past necessarily restrict the references given,\nsince I shall rarely refer you to a book not in our own library.\n\nThe list in your hands is in no sense complete, or even representative.\nIt is submitted to you in the hope that it may be suggestive. For the\ndegree of success of the course is in your hands. It must depend on\nthe individual student. I am trying to introduce to you a literature\nof objective, rather than of subjective, value and appeal, a field so\noften open to men, one so rarely open to women. It seems to me that\nthis factor is a necessity in the life of every woman who hopes to be\nsuccessful. I can point out to you the beauties and glories of it. I\ncan suggest a thousand more. But whether or not you will learn, as a\nresult of this course, the essentials of the scientific method, whether\nor not you will learn to apply them, whether or not you will be able to\nwalk through the world because of your intelligent knowledge of them as\none who sees more than he has seen and understands better than he has\nunderstood--all this must depend largely on you.\n\n\n\n\n                         The Scientific Method\n\n\nIN CONTRAST to poetry, essays, and fiction, which deal very largely\nwith the subjective side of life, scientific literature aims to be\nobjective. This is the fact upon which much of its value depends.\nFor a great many years it has been the practise of men to read both\ntypes--Shakespeare and Darwin, Dickens and Tyndall. But if you were\nto inquire about the reading of the women of these same generations,\nyou would find that while they were well-versed in literature of the\nsubjective type, they were often ignorant of even the names of works\nof the objective type. These they frequently conceive to be always\nand only text-books. This is even true of some members of college\nfaculties. How much more true must it be of others.\n\nThis difference between the intellectual diet of men and women is due\npartly to a failure of women to observe those factors which create\nsuccess for men, partly to the lack of competition between women\nand men. These again are inter-dependent, since if women had always\ncompeted in business with men, they would have been forced to observe\nfor themselves the factors which had made their competitors successful.\nBut however the difference may have arisen, it exists even today. There\nare always times in a man’s life when escape from his own point of\nview is essential both to his happiness and to his mental vigor. He\nneeds relief from strain and worry. He secures it, frequently, from his\nobjective reading. Many college women, on the other hand, take their\ndegrees without ever realizing the possibility of finding relief in\nobjective literature. It is to fill the need for a new, fresh point\nof view among women that such a list as the one I have given you is\nframed. It embraces many of the best works in literature among the\nproducts of the scientific world, and is adequate to point you to\nthat universe outside yourself in which you can find relief from the\nconstant and wearing contact of personalities.\n\nBooks such as these, which help to lessen the emotional intensity and\nmental acidity of a business or professional man’s life, are products\nof what is known as the _scientific method_. It is well that we\nshould spend some time considering the steps in this method, together\nwith illustrations of them, before we attempt to peruse any of the\nbooks themselves.\n\nThe scientific method consists essentially in the following processes:\nthe observation of phenomena, the collection and classification of\ndata concerning these phenomena, the formation of a generalization, a\ntheory, which shall attempt to describe all the data thus classified,\nand, finally, a statement of the law according to which the observed\nphenomena occur.\n\nObservation is, of course, one of the earliest mental processes of a\nchild. A fly moves. The sun rises and sets. A child observes them;\nbut he makes no progress scientifically. Neither would the race have\nmade any progress scientifically had it not observed also that a\ngiven length of time intervened between the rising and the setting\nof the sun, that there were variations, and that those variations\nwere concomitant with the seasons. There you have the beginning of a\nscientific method. There are the observation of phenomena, _and the\ncollection of data_.\n\nNext began an orderly classification of all the data collected. Data\nconcerning the motions of the moon were classified, for example, in\na separate category from those concerning the motions of the sun.\nThe present day biological sciences still furnish many specific\nillustrations of this stage in the scientific method, as in the study\nof heredity.\n\nTo generalize required much more advanced work. In mathematics, for\nexample, men made such generalizations as this:\n\n3 + 2 = 2 + 3.\n\nAt length the further idea occurred to someone that simple numbers\nbeing added could be rearranged in order without any effect upon the\ntruth of their results, and the commutative law of arithmetic could\nbe stated. In astronomy we find that men once said: “The sun revolves\nabout the earth.” This was an early generalization, or theory. Then\nthe conclusion was forced upon them that that theory could not be\nmaintained unless certain other phenomena were to be over-looked,\nphenomena which contradicted the former theory, and could not possibly\nbe explained, that is, described, by it. Then men said: “No, the earth\nmoves about the sun.” Still the theory was not quantitative, nor even\naltogether comprehensive. At this time, for example, the earth’s orbit\nwas thought to be necessarily a circle, since theology taught that\nthis was the symbol of perfection in nature. This belief is not so\ninexplicable in light of the fact that a perfect circle is sufficient\nas a description of certain phenomena observed in other fields. But\nfurther observations forced men to change even this description, so\nthat they traced the earth’s orbit as a series of sections of circles.\n\nEven this was not an entirely adequate version of the truth. But\ngranted that a given theory accounts for only a part of the phenomena\nobserved, still it is more nearly ideal than the chaos in thought that\npreceded it. Changes in theories can be accounted for by that same\nphenomenon, evolution, which explains so many biological changes.\n\nAs soon as a theory has been devised which will explain two or more\nof the phenomena observed, it can be tested. Then, and then only, can\nyou discover wherein it is weak. Whether or not it is true does not,\nof course, matter. It is for this reason that theories are sometimes\ncalled “working hypotheses.” Their object is merely to make some\nprogress toward accurate knowledge. As for their usefulness, it is\nobvious. If some man had not been bold enough to suggest that the sun\nmoved about the earth, no one would ever have discovered what we now\nbelieve to be the fact, that the sun and earth move about their common\ncenter of gravity. Now, these former theories are still convenient as\nmethods of describing the phenomena they attempted to explain. They\nare therefore still useful. It is, for instance, sometimes more simple\nto consider one motion of the earth-sun system at a time. It is then\nthat these older theories are used. A theory is discarded only when\nit is inconsistent within itself, when it is both inconvenient and\nincorrect, or when it does not explain even one phase of the phenomena\nwhich it attempts to explain. A further example of the out-of-date\nbut by no means useless hypothesis is the commutative law referred to\nabove. At first it applied only to simple numbers. Then the invention\nof algebra widened its scope. Here again we see that the partial nature\nof an explanation need not condemn it, but that only incorrectness,\nthat is, inconsistency within itself, and the failure to describe any\nof the phases of that which it attempts to describe in entirety, prove\nit to be worthy of abandonment.\n\nIn general we are interested in so wording a principle that it will\nclassify and refer to many phenomena. We are interested, therefore,\nin Darwin, who had the intellectual courage to take the facts he\nfound, and to base his conclusions upon them, irrespective of\nhis personal opinion. He was then free to feel that anyone with\nvocabulary, training, and intelligence like his would, after similar\ninvestigations, reach the same conclusions. His ideas were not, it is\nworth while to note, received with any considerable degree of warmth,\nin his day as, in some cases, in ours. (It is certain, however, that\nthe greatest disparagement of them today comes from ignorance, although\nit is also true that some of his theories have not been upheld in\nexactness and entirety by later experiments.)\n\nA theory differs from speculation in this respect: no theory has a\nright to exist which cannot be tried and verified by experiment.\n\nThe laws of the younger sciences have not yet reached the place where\nthey can be stated mathematically. But in Physics, for example, this is\nnot true. “Any two bodies in the universe are attracted to each other\nby a force equal to a constant times the product of the two masses\ndivided by the square of the distance between them,” said Newton. “The\nattractive force varies as the masses and inversely as the distance\nbetween them,” his predecessors had said. But no predictions could be\nmade on the theory they had stated. On Newton’s theory predictions can\nbe made. It is therefore called a law, a mathematically worded, and\ntherefore rigorously precise, law. It is on such laws, and on such\nlaws alone, that prophecies can be safely based. This type of law is\nthe summit of man’s attempt to treat life by the scientific method.\n\n\n\n\n                                  Law\n\n\nTHERE is today, I believe, but one university in this country which has\nbeen founded not for the purpose of educating the youth of the land,\nbut for the purpose of carrying on research work and making scientific\ninvestigation, to the end that it might make permanent additions to the\nsum of the world’s knowledge. That university chose for its motto these\nwords: “Veritas vos liberabit,” “the truth shall set you free.” Let us\nask ourselves why a university with such an aim should have chosen such\na motto.\n\nIn Pearson’s “Grammar of Science” there occurs an analysis of the types\nof “laws,” with their meanings, and the results of their operation.\nYou will recall his opinions. A civil law can be evaded. As Crothers\nhas observed in his essay “The Alphabetical Mind,” if a law of the\ncommonwealth is broken, the breaker pays the penalty only if he is\ncaught. For broken moral laws you pay the penalty within yourself, and\nsociety shares it.\n\nBut you cannot violate a scientific law. You can only illustrate it.\nWhen it is said that a natural law is broken, the meaning is not that\nthe law itself is broken, but that the breaker is broken. If I attempt\nto fly off the roof, not knowing the consequences, my ignorance does\nnot save me. I merely furnish an additional example of the impartiality\nof the scientific law. “Can’t” does indeed exist even in “the bright\nlexicon of youth,” for nature’s laws cannot be broken. These laws can,\nhowever, be disregarded. Thus when a flyer falls, it is not the law\nwhich has been at fault, but the flyer who has been ignorant. His fall\nis merely the fulfillment of a law which he did not fully appreciate.\n\nIt is, then, only when a law of nature becomes known that it is\npossible for the individual not to break the law, but rather to avoid\nillustrating it except at will. That is the least reason for your need\nof knowing the law.\n\nNow, at the basis of every science there lie two assumptions, namely\nthat a cause will produce its effects and that a similar cause will\nproduce similar effects, irrespective of time and place, except so\nfar as absolute time and space are concerned. For example, if today\nan apple falls to the ground from a given height at a given place, it\nwill fall in precisely the same way tomorrow, and would have fallen\njust so a thousand years ago. Change its place and position, and it\nwill still fall so, except for those changes and their effects. These,\nthen, are the _assumptions_ underlying science. The scientific\nmethod, as we have said, consists in the observation of phenomena,\nthe collection and classification of data, generalizations concerning\nthe phenomena observed and the attempt to describe all of them; and,\nwhere the science has become exact, mathematical statements of the\nlaws found to govern the phenomena. Sciences so built up are divided\ninto two classes. Those stating laws which are used for the purpose of\ncontributing to man’s knowledge are called pure sciences. Those which\nare used for commercial or industrial purposes, or for investigation in\nfields different from their own, are called _applied sciences_.\n\nSometimes a fifth step intervenes between the generalizations and the\nstatement in mathematical form. This step is the formation of what is\nknown as a “working hypothesis,” a statement which covers some, but\nnot all, of the phenomena observed and classified, a statement which\nwill serve as a basis for experimental and logical tests, and as a\npoint of departure for investigation in new fields. One of the most\nremarkable illustrations of such a process is found in the history\nof the Newtonian Theory of Gravitation. Galileo believed that any\nobject falling to the ground changed its velocity at the same rate\nas any other object falling at the same place at the same time, and\nconsequently that if two objects fell from the same place at the same\ntime they would reach their common destination together. (Now, velocity\nis distance per unit of time; the change in velocity per unit of time\nis the “acceleration.”) Galileo’s idea was that these objects would\nhave the same acceleration. He used the modern experimental method of\nverification. He dropped balls of unequal weight and size from the\nleaning tower of Pisa. They reached the ground at almost the same time.\nThe variation observed was due to the fact that a ball of larger size\nwould meet a greater air resistance. (Verification of this deviation\nhad to wait, however, for the invention of the vacuum tube.)\n\nAfter Galileo had made so much progress in his search for the law that\ngoverned the attraction of two bodies, Huygens measured the constant\nacceleration by means of a pendulum experiment. The period of the\npendulum is known to be 2π√(h/g)[1]. Huygens’ error was due solely to\ntime errors of his day.\n\nNext, Copernicus, working in an entirely different field, decided that\nthe motions of the planets could better be described by thinking of\nthem as moving about the sun, a description which involved the change\nfrom a geocentric to a heliocentric concept, since they had formerly\nbeen supposed to have moved about the earth. Kepler further advanced\nthis descriptive process by the statement of three laws governing\nthat motion: (1) every planet moves in an elliptical orbit with the\nsun at one focus, (2) each planet moves in such a fashion that equal\nareas are swept out by the focal radii in equal periods of time (this\ninvolves a change of velocity), (3) the ratio of the square of the\nperiod to the cube of the distance (from the center of the planet to\nthe center of the sun) in each case is a constant.\n\nIt was Newton who deduced from these laws concerning the attractions\nof planets and sun generalizations concerning the attractions of\nany two bodies. He did not do this, however, until he had further\ndeduced from Kepler’s laws certain statements: (1) that the force\nacting on the planet is directed along the focal radius, and varies\ninversely as the distance from the planet to the sun (this from the\nfirst law of Kepler); (2) that the only force acting on the planet\nis a deflecting force (this from Kepler’s second law); (3) that the\nforce acting is proportional to the product of the masses of the\nplanet and the sun (this from Kepler’s third law). It was on these\nspecific generalizations that Newton based his general one: any two\nmasses attract each other by a force which is directly proportional\nto the product of the masses, and inversely proportional to the\nsquare of the distance between them (F ∝ mm'/r^2). With the aid of\ncertain experiments he came to this conclusion: F = Gmm'/r^2 (G being\ndefinitely determined by the choice of units), 6.6576 × 10^{-8} in the\nc. g. s. system.\n\nHere, then, we have a law formulated which expresses the attraction\nof any two objects anywhere. Weight (the force with which an object\nis attracted to the earth) is but an illustration of this law. That\none statement accurately describes both the apple falling to the earth\nand the earth moving about the sun. That same law once devised for\nfinite attractions has been applied to the infinitesimal and infinite\nfields. Here, in the fields of electricity and astronomy respectively,\nvariations occur. In both cases either velocity or mass, or both, have\napproached either 0 or ∞ as a limit. We are then trying to measure one\nset of quantities in terms of another set not comparable with them.\nFor instance, 50,000 miles of error is unavoidable in astronomical\nmeasurements. Here centimeters would be useless. With these two\nexplicable exceptions the law of gravity explains all the observed\nphenomena.\n\nIt must not be supposed that simplicity is indeed the final ideal\nof a statement of law. Henry Adams bewails, nay, laments, in his\nautobiography, this idea that we should alternate between the complex\nand the simple in an infinite series! Yet we can see that Galileo’s\nstatement was simple; Kepler’s complex; Newton’s first, more complex;\nhis later one, more simple; Einstein’s far more complex. Poincaré, over\nwhom Mr. Adams weeps, states only what he has observed, seeing, as Mr.\nAdams could not, that it is futile to bewail a fact or a law, and that\nit is sensible to understand it, if possible.\n\nFor many years physicists believed that a simple law existed to\ndescribe all phenomena observable. This was an assumption. Poincaré\nworks upon no such theory. He has observed; he has stated his\nobservations. There is, he thinks, no indication of whether or not\nthe statement finally evolved will be simple. That will depend upon\nthe stage the race has reached when it shall have ceased to exist,\nor shall have created something to take its place. If this seems\nunorthodox, consider that in his day Galileo was thought theologically\nincorrect.\n\nIllustrations of scientific law are, however, to be found in other than\nphysical and mathematical fields.\n\n“Omnis cellula a cellula,” says the biologist. This is a scientific\nlaw. It, too, is based on the assumption that a cause produces its\neffect irrespective of time and place. To be sure, it cannot be\nexperimentally proved to have been true throughout past ages, or to be\nabout to be true in the future; yet it is, indeed, a scientific law.\nBut this type we call a _general law_.\n\n“Every individual,” says the biologist again, “repeats the history\nof the race. Ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny.” This is the general\nlaw which has governed many teachers in their methods. Such teachers\nhave preferred to the logical development that arrangement of their\nsubject matter which most nearly corresponds to the actual historical\ndevelopment of the subject itself.\n\n“Qualities developed by individuals during their life-time are not\ninherited by their offspring.” Here again comes the familiar ring of\nthe scientific law. Let us notice here, as in the discussion of the law\nof gravity, that the ability to use the forces described in a law, not\nignorance of the law, enables men to rise above circumstances. Here in\nthe law of the inheritance of man by man we see it. The evil is not\ninherited. True. Neither is the good inherited. It is a two-edged sword\nwhich works both ways. But notice this: _those who have developed\ngood qualities can, if they realize the importance of this law,\nsurround their children with a good environment_.\n\nIt is knowledge of the truth which sets men free. Thus, and thus only,\ncan we walk freely through the universe, controlling our actions, not\ncontrolled by our environment. Thus, and thus only, can we be masters\nof our fates. “_Veritas_ vos liberabit!”\n\n\nFOOTNOTES:\n\n[Footnote 1: p = period of pendulum, h = length of pendulum, π =\n3.14159+, g = acceleration of gravity.]\n\n\n\n\n                          The Fourth Dimension\n\n\n References:\n\n _Flatland_                                   A Square\n\n _Mathematical Essays and Recreations_        Schubert\n\n _The Fourth Dimension Simply Explained_\n\n                                           Published by Munn & Co., Inc.\n                                      Edited by Henry P. Manning, Ph. D.\n\n\nTHE fourth dimension, however simply it may have been explained,\nwas quickly adopted by the spiritualists as a place of abode for\nthose spirits with whom they claimed to have communication. The\nconfusion which followed was alarmingly wide-spread. One Schubert,\na mathematician, writes quite seriously for the express purpose of\nmeeting this pernicious propaganda with accurate information concerning\nthe mathematician’s use and the spiritualists’ misuse of this term\n“fourth dimension.”\n\nThat misconception is no longer vital. But another has arisen,\nespecially persistent since the time when Einstein’s theory became a\nmatter of interest to the general public, which is causing trouble\nin its own fashion among non-mathematical thinkers. This newest\nmisconception is based on the idea that there is a physical fourth\ndimension, similar to the third dimension and of a like nature.\n\nSince both of these misconceptions rest upon a misunderstanding of the\nsame mathematical concept (that of dimension), it seems worth while for\nus to examine in some detail the precise scope of those algebraic and\ngeometric concepts which the mathematician denominates “dimensionality.”\n\nLet us consider the matter first from a geometer’s point of view. A\npoint is assumed by the mathematician to have no dimension. As soon as\na line is supposed to exist, there are an infinite number of points\nexistent on that line. In order to locate any particular point on the\nline, certain conventions are necessary. Of these the first is the\nassumption of an origin; the next, the choice of a unit of measurement,\nand a one-to-one correspondence between a number system and the points\non the line. To express this less technically, it is usual to mark one\npoint zero and, after a unit of measurement has been adopted, first to\nassign a positive and a negative direction from the zero point, then to\nestablish a one-to-one correspondence between the points on the line\nand the members of the real number system.\n\nA thermometer scale is an application of this mathematical theory.\nOn the centigrade thermometer, for example, to every positive number\nthere corresponds a temperature above freezing, and to every negative\nnumber there corresponds a temperature below freezing. Notice that word\n“application.” It illustrates a point of view much used in mathematics\nand applied sciences. The mathematical theory of which the thermometer\nscale was an “application” does not deal with the temperature,\nnor with the thermometer; but since that particular mathematical\ntheory describes a thermometer scale more accurately than any other\nmathematical theory describes it, we may speak of the thermometer as an\napplication of the theory, and, therefore, as an illustration of the\none-dimensional geometry.\n\nIf in our mathematical theory we have assumed the existence of a\nstraight line, that line may be used to represent a one-dimensional\nform, or manifold; for a single measurement will locate uniquely any\npoint on the line, and a single point on the line will locate uniquely\nany measurement. A two-dimensional form, or plane, can be obtained by\nassuming the existence of a single point outside the given line. It is\nthen possible to derive all other points and lines in the plane.\n\nNow, in order to locate uniquely any particular point in this plane\nwe set up a so-called _co-ordinate system_, consisting of\ntwo intersecting straight lines called axes. The point of their\nintersection is called the origin. A unit of measurement is chosen for\neach axis, two directions are chosen for each axis, and a one-to-one\ncorrespondence is established between the points on each axis and the\nmembers of the real number system.\n\nThis is a very commonly used scheme for the location of houses in a\ncity in which the two principal streets divide the city, north and\nsouth, east and west. The mathematical theory had made it evident\nthat two numbers, or measurements, made parallel to each axis, are\nsufficient to locate a point uniquely, and that a point is sufficient\nto determine two numbers or measurements. But notice this. As the\nthermometer scale could not be said to have been identical with the\nmathematical theory of a one-dimensional manifold, so this mathematical\ntheory of a two-dimensional plane is used to describe the streets of\nthe city not because the streets can be considered to have no breadth\nor thickness, but because the elements on which the attention of a\nstranger are focused are more adequately described by the geometric\nplane, lines, and points than by any other mathematical theory.\n\nIt is, then, clear, that in none of these discussions has the physical\nexistence of the geometric forms--points, lines, and planes--been\nassumed or proved, except as concepts in the physical mind of the\nmathematician. Their physical existence does not enter into the\ndiscussion; and although the physical phenomena are described in terms\nof the mathematical concepts, they are no more identical with them\nthan a table, the physical object, is identical with “table,” the word\nwhich describes it.\n\nAs it was possible to obtain a two-dimensional plane from a\none-dimensional manifold by assuming a point to lie outside the\none-dimensional form, so it is possible to obtain a three-dimensional\nform, or space, by assuming a point to lie outside the two-dimensional\nplane. Further, by adding to our previous co-ordinate system a\nthird straight line perpendicular to the other two at their point\nof intersection, we can use three measurements to determine a point\nin three-dimensional space, and conversely we can use a point in\nthree-dimensional space to determine three measurements, or three\nnumbers.\n\nThis mathematical theory of three dimensions is frequently used to\ndescribe the physical space in which we live. The reasons for so using\nit are rather obvious. It is to be noticed, however, that latitude\nand longitude, having for their axes the equator and the great circle\nthrough Greenwich, determine points on the earth’s surface, which is\nnot a plane, but a curved surface, and that they involve only two\nmeasurements, and not three. A mathematician would therefore call\ngeography a two-dimensional geometry, although points in a physical\nspace on a curved surface are located by that scheme. This being\nunderstood, it becomes evident that the mathematician does not confine\nhimself to the use of any single theory for the description of physical\nspace, but rather chooses for each purpose a theory which, while\nconsistent with itself, brings out most adequately those features in\nphysical space in which he is at the time most interested.\n\nSuppose we turn to algebra and see what there corresponds to the\ngeometric development we have been tracing. You remember that in the\none-dimensional geometry one measurement determined a point. Now, in\nalgebra, _an equation in one variable_ can be used to represent\nthat point; that is, x = a, where _a_ is a constant representing\nany member of the real number system. The equation in algebra and the\npoint on the line in geometry are merely different expressions of the\nsame mathematical fact. Again, in correspondence to a line in the\nplane there is an equation of the first degree in two variables:\n\nax + by + c = 0\n\nOne may thus talk with equal truth and ease of the intersection of\ntwo lines in the plane or of a solution of two linear equations in\ntwo variables. Or we may speak on the one hand of two straight lines\nin geometry being perpendicular to each other, and on the other hand\nof the algebraic coefficients of two linear equations satisfying a\ncondition. In geometry there exists a plane, and in algebra there is\ncorrespondingly a linear equation in three variables. In geometry three\nlines may be perpendicular to each other; in algebra the coefficients\nof the equations of the three lines satisfy a condition. We represent\nthese parallel developments in algebra and geometry by the following\ntable:\n\n     GEOMETRY                                ALGEBRA\n\n Point on a line                       x = a\n Line in a plane                       ax + by + c = 0\n Plane in three-dimensional space      ax + by + cz + d = 0\n\nTwo methods, one algebraic and one geometric, thus often appear for the\ndescription of the same fact. It is merely a matter of convenience to\nthe mathematician as to which he will use for the description of any\nparticular phenomenon.\n\nNow, it is easily to be seen that we can conceive of more than three\nvariables in algebra. In fact, so soon as the thought occurs to us we\ncan write down an equation involving four variables:\n\nax + my + cz + lw + e = 0;\n\nand if we have four such equations we can find a common solution. Since\nthere are many quantities in nature which involve four variables or\nmore, we obviously have a use for the algebra which deals with four\nvariables or more. Yet we know that the four variables used for a\ndescription of such phenomena do not exist physically. In the same way,\nas we have said, we know that the mathematical point does not exist in\nthe physical sense. Yet why should we limit our use of the geometrical\nlanguage to those fields in which there is a physical representation\nof the point? In geometry a point of intersection corresponds to a\ncommon solution of sets of equations. Equations in four variables have\na common solution. Is it not therefore as reasonable to assert that,\nsince the values of the four variables are uniquely determined, four\nthree-dimensional spaces then have a common point of intersection; as\nit is to say that, since three equations in three variables determine\nthe values of the variables, three two-dimensional planes then have a\npoint of intersection? The planes, S_{2}'s, lie in an S_{3}. Extending\nthe geometric conventions we may then state that four S_{3}'s lying in\na four-dimensional form S_{4}, meet in a point.\n\nThere is in this language no implication concerning the physical\nexistence of any space. Then what shall we say of the question:\nshall we or shall we not speak of a fourth dimension? Why, simply\nthat it mathematically reduces itself to this question: when four\nvariables must be used, are the geometric terms ever a more convenient\ndescription than the algebraic terms? Inasmuch as the algebraic\nscheme can be extended indefinitely, must not the question of an\n_n_-dimensional geometry be considered?\n\nWhen this is understood, and the possibilities of the transformation of\nthe expressions of one language into those of the other are clear, the\nconnection supposed to have existed between the fourth dimension of the\nmathematicians and the fourth dimension of the spiritualists dims from\nfaintness to non-existence. Henceforth it is unmistakably clear that\nthose who scoff at the Einstein Theory or who object to it because to\nthem it seems to imply the existence of a physical fourth dimension,\nare dupes of their own incorrect thinking upon incorrect hypotheses\nand flagrant misuses of the _mathematical_ term, _fourth\ndimension_.\n\n\n\n\n            The Fourth Dimension and Non-Euclidean Geometry\n\n\nWE ARE to study the application of the ideas concerning the fourth\ndimension and non-Euclidean geometry which is found in Einstein’s\ntheory. But since Einstein’s theory is expressed in terms which involve\nan understanding of these ideas, it may be well to try first to\nunderstand the ideas themselves.\n\nWe have seen that a mathematician could use a geometrical form of\nfour dimensions, S_{4}, to represent any function dependent upon four\nvariables. If you will further consider for a moment that any event or\nphenomenon of the physical universe can be located in physical space by\nthree measurements, and that a fourth is needed to locate it in time,\nyou will readily see why a four-, rather than a three-, dimensional\ngeometry is used whenever time affects an event.\n\nBut some of you object to time being thus associated with space,\nbecause the units of measurement used to locate a point in S_{4} are\nin terms of miles or meters, while time is measured by units of hours\nand years. Yet you are entirely accustomed to such mathematical usage\nas that the area of a rectangle (measured in square inches) equals the\nproduct of the length and the breadth (each measured by linear inches),\nand to the interest on a sum of money being equal to the principal\n(given in dollars) times the rate of interest (given in percentage).\nMoreover in statistical graphs do you not mark the time (in years) on\nthe _x_-axis, and the price (in dollars) of the commodity on the\n_y_-axis? Can you not then interpret the resulting curve with\nease? Every physicist is accustomed to associating the volume and the\npressure of a gas, nor does he require that the units be the same. So\nthe association of time and space can, from the point of view of the\nmathematician, be readily associated and with equal readiness described\nby a four-dimensional geometry.\n\nBut there is still another reason why it is convenient to use a\nfour-dimensional geometry. Have you ever observed that if the ends of\na loop are considered as fixed in a plane, and motions are assumed to\nbe limited to rotation and translation in the plane, the loop cannot be\nunlooped?\n\n[Illustration]\n\nIf, however, motion in S_{3} is permitted, the cord may be unlooped by\npicking up the portion at C, turning it towards the right, and laying\nit down again, a motion which can be described algebraically as well\nas geometrically. Similarly, a knot with the ends fastened cannot be\nuntied in S_{3}. But the algebraic conditions similar to those in the\nprevious case can be set up, and, by an extension of the geometrical\nlanguage, the knot can be untied in S_{4}. Since this last geometrical\nexpression is easier to say than the corresponding expression in\nalgebra, it is more apt to be used than the algebraic terms are, to\nexplain this phenomenon.\n\nAgain, it is sometimes easier to use Euclidean than non-Euclidean\ngeometry in a description of phenomena of space. For example, you use\nEuclidean geometry in every-day life in the measurements of plots of\nground. Although you know that physical phenomena in space have three,\nnot two, dimensions, you assume a field to be a plane, and, if it be a\nrectangle in shape, you assume that it has an area equal to its length\ntimes its breadth. Why? Because that describes it more nearly than any\nother mathematical figure does. You know that the earth’s surface is\ncurved. Yet in measuring fields you do not use the method of measuring\na part of the surface of a sphere. Why? Because the difference in\nmeasurement between a plane surface and the slight degree of curvature\nof the earth’s surface over a very few acres or miles is so slight\nas to be nearly negligible. It is a disregard of the curvature of\nthe earth’s surface which makes it possible for us to use Euclidean\ngeometry in this case. The Euclidean postulate, sometimes stated: the\nsum of the angles of a triangle cannot exceed 180°, is not fulfilled\nif the triangle is traced on a curved surface instead of on a plane.\nThis can be easily seen by drawing such a triangle on a baseball. But\neven on the surface of a sphere Euclidean geometry may sometimes be\npreferable to non-Euclidean geometry as a convenient description of\nexisting phenomena.\n\n\n\n\n                    Einstein’s Theory of Gravitation\n\n\nMAY we for a moment recall a few facts and a point of view from the\npreceding lecture? Since three measurements are needed to determine the\nposition of an event or a phenomenon in space and a fourth is necessary\nto determine the time of the event, physical phenomena are said to take\nplace in a four-dimensional manifold. A second fact to be recalled is\nthat a change of curvature sometimes makes it more convenient to use\nnon-Euclidean geometry instead of Euclidean geometry. For Euclidean\ngeometry is based on the assumption that the sum of the angles of a\ntriangle is equal to two right angles. This assumption is fulfilled if\nmeasurements are made on small sections of the earth’s surface: that\nis, the deviation from this assumption is so small with respect to\nthe quantities measured that it cannot be detected. When, however, a\ntriangle is measured from New York to London to Naples, the deviation\nis noticeable, and it is then more convenient to use non-Euclidean\ngeometry in which the straight line is replaced by the shortest line\nbetween two points, the geodetic. Either geometry can be used for each\ncase, but it is more convenient to use sometimes one and sometimes\nthe other. This is an illustration of the scientist’s point of view\nin choosing the most convenient of two equally logical methods of\nrepresenting phenomena.\n\nThe Ptolemaic method of describing the motions of the sun and planets\nabout the earth as a center is not more incorrect than the Copernican\nmethod of describing the earth’s motions about the sun as a center, nor\nis the latter more incorrect than the Newtonian method of considering\nthe sun and earth as revolving about the center of gravity of the\nsystem. But sometimes one method is more convenient than another and\none is more general than the others. Similarly while Newton’s law of\ngravitation will probably always be used to describe slow motions,\nEinstein’s theory may be used to explain fast motions and to account\nfor some apparent exceptions to Newton’s law.\n\nSince Einstein’s theory rests essentially upon the concept of\nrelativity applied to space and time as well as to motion, we shall\nbriefly discuss the theory of relativity and then state Einstein’s\ndeductions and the mathematical and experimental verifications of these\ndeductions.\n\nThe concept of relative motion is old. The table, for instance, is\nat rest with respect to the earth, but it with the earth is rushing\nthrough space as the earth moves around the sun. Again, if a man in a\nmoving train lets a ball fall, to him it appears to fall in a straight\nline if the train has a constant velocity, while to a man on the street\nit appears to follow a parabolic curve. Newtonian mechanics admits the\nrelativity of motion, but assumes space and time absolute, that is,\nindependent of the observer.\n\nOn the assumption of absolute time and space it should be possible to\ndetect the earth’s motion through the ether, the medium by means of\nwhich light is supposed to be transmitted. For if the light waves were\nto move through the ether with a velocity _c_ (186,000 miles\nper second), and the earth with a velocity _q_, then when the\nearth is moving in the direction of the light waves, we should obtain\nfor the apparent velocity of light c - q, and when the earth moves in\nthe opposite direction, we should obtain for the apparent velocity of\nlight c + q. Hence different velocities for the transmission of light\nwould be obtained according to the relative directions of the light\nwaves with respect to the direction of the earth’s motion. Did such a\ndifference exist, the Michelson-Morley experiment would have detected\nit, for the experimental error was only 1/100 of the quantity to be\nmeasured. The experiment had a negative result, proving that absolute\nmotion with respect to the ether cannot be detected. It had long been\naccepted that absolute uniform rectilinear motion could not be detected\nby a mechanical experiment. For example, an experiment on a moving\ntrain is the same as on the earth, provided the train moves without\nacceleration. Michelson’s experiment added that electro-dynamical\nexperiments do not indicate whether or not the observer is moving\nuniformly and rectilinearly. Then from experiment is deduced the\nfollowing “special theory of relativity.” This theorem states: “All\nlaws of physical nature which have been formulated with reference to a\ndefinite co-ordinate system are valid, in precisely the same form, when\nreferred to another co-ordinate system which is in uniform rectilinear\nmotion with respect to the first.” This empirical law is called the\nspecial theory of relativity because it affirms the relativity of\nuniform translations only, that is, of a very special class of motions\n(_Vide_ pages 10-11). This contradiction of the ether theory is\nthe point of divergence of the old and new physics.\n\nLorentz and Fitzgerald solve the logical difficulty by making a new\nphysical hypothesis, that “all bodies, which are put in motion with\nreference to the ether, suffer contraction to √(1 - q^2/c^2) of their\nlength in the direction of their motion.” (_Vide_ page 11.)\n\nThe state of affairs is this, then. According to the old theory\nabsolute motion with respect to the material ether exists. But\nsuch motion cannot be observed experimentally. Therefore, special\nhypotheses must be invented to explain why it cannot be perceived. In\nother words the special theory of relativity does not hold, but since\nphysical phenomena take place as if it were true, special hypotheses\nmust be invented in terms of which the experimental evidence can be\nexpressed. According to the new physics, since phenomena occur as if\nether did not exist, ether lacks meaning physically and therefore does\nnot exist in the physical sense. Hence the special theory of relativity\nis a more convenient and simpler expression of physical phenomena than\nthe older theory.\n\nEinstein claims to reconcile the principle of relativity, the\nnon-existence of the ether, and the transmission of light, by a\nrevision of the assumptions concerning the measurement of time and\nspace, a revision which he accomplishes by generalizing his special\ntheory of relativity, that is, by applying the principle of relativity\nto all motions instead of to uniform rectilinear motions only. In other\nwords all measurements of space and time depend upon systems moving\nwith respect to each other. If you were in an empty box, would you hit\nthe box or would the box hit you? If you fell with the acceleration of\ngravity, your hat, dropped at the same time, would stay beside you. In\nthat case you would suppose the hat to be at rest or in uniform motion.\n\nThe following is an illustration of what is meant by the relativity\nof the measurement of time. The illustration deals with two events\nof equal duration measured first in two systems at rest or moving\nuniformly with respect to each other, secondly in two systems not so\nrestricted in their motions.\n\nCase I. Let K and K' be two trains standing side by side; A and B,\nA' and B', clocks in the trains, also side by side. Send a light\nsignal from clock A to clock B and reflect it back again to A. Suppose\nthat clock A has run 2 seconds. Then it takes 2 seconds for light to\ntravel the distance AB twice. Since according to our postulate light\nis propagated in all directions with the same speed _c_ (the\nMichelson experiment), it takes as long to go the distance AB as it\ntakes to go the distance BA. If, then, clock A registers 12 when the\nlight signal is sent, and an observer at B has been told to set his\nclock at 12.1 when he receives the light signal, then clocks A and B\nare synchronized. Similarly the clocks in K' can be synchronized with\nthose in K as well as with those in K', since the two systems are at\nrest or in uniform motion with respect to each other.\n\nCase II. Let all four clocks be synchronized by the preceding method.\nLet K move relatively to K' with terrific velocity _q_ in the\ndirection A to B. Then A and B are at rest in K, A' and B' are at rest\nin K'. Suppose A and A' are in immediate proximity when both register\n12, and that B is in immediate proximity to B', which also registers\n12. An observer on K will say that A coincides with A' simultaneously\nwhen B coincides with B'. Now flash a light signal from the common\nposition A, when both clocks there indicate 12. The rays reach B' when\nits clock reads 12.1 by case I. Clock B, however, has moved a distance\n_q_ from the position B at the end of one second, and will have\nmoved slightly farther before the light will have reached it. Hence\nfor an observer on K' the light will take longer than one second to\ntravel from A to B. If now it is reflected back to A, it will take less\nthan one second to reach A, according to an observer on K', because A\nis moving towards the light. To an observer in K, however, the time\nlight takes to travel the distance AB in one direction is the same that\nit takes to travel that distance in the opposite direction, according\nto the postulate established by the Michelson-Morley experiment, that\nlight is propagated with equal velocities in all directions.\n\nThe conclusion is that events of equal duration in system K are of\nunequal duration when measured from K'. The conception of duration has\nbecome relative. (_Vide_ pages 14-16.) Similarly the lengths of\na body determined according as to whether the observer is or is not\nin a system at rest with respect to the body being measured, vary in\naccordance with the Lorentz-Fitzgerald contraction. This contraction is\nnot, however, a physical effect, as they thought, but is an indication\nof the differences in the methods of measurement. A mathematical\ntransformation is used to express this fact.\n\nOne of the results of this special theory of relativity is to connect\nthe Law of the Conservation of Mass with the Law of the Conservation of\nEnergy, and to show that the former is not strictly in agreement with\nthe latter and must be considered as being only approximately true.\n(_Vide_ page 19.) For mass is not independent of velocity, energy\nis found to have the property of inertia, and mass depends upon energy.\n\nEinstein’s next step is to make the mathematical generalizations\nwhich enable him to remove the restriction on the application of his\ntheory of relativity. Geometrical relativity of space can be expressed\nby a transformation. Non-Euclidean geometry of a fourth dimensional\nspace is next used to simplify the expression of physical laws.\nEinstein then shows the connection between gravitation and inertia\n(_Vide_ page 42), and arrives at the “principle of equivalence,”\naccording to which gravitational and inertial mass are the same. This\nimplies the postulate of an unlimited relativity of motions; “for\nsince all phenomena are to depend only on the mutual position and\nmotion of bodies, reference to any particular co-ordinate system no\nlonger occurs, _i. e._, no reference system plays a unique role\nin the statement of physical laws, as was required by the Newtonian\nsystem.” Newtonian laws then appear as special cases, applicable in an\ninfinitely small domain and as a first approximation of Einstein’s law.\n\nEinstein’s work leads then to this result: “The Law of Inertia of\nNewton and Galileo states: ‘A point under no forces moves uniformly and\nrectilinearly.’ The Einstein Law, which comprises both inertial and\ngravitational effects, asserts: ‘The world-line of a material point is\na geodetic line in the space-time continuum.’”\n\nThe mathematical and experimental confirmations of the Einstein\nLaw are as follows: The new equations, developed from a different\nhypothesis and by a different method, actually degenerate into the\nNewtonian formula for general mass-attraction (_mm'_/_r_^2)\nfor a first approximation. If the equations are worked out to a\nsecond approximation, a quantitatively exact explanation of the\nanomalous motion of Mercury’s perihelion appears. In a strong\ngravitational field curvature of light rays should be manifested.\nThis was verified by an observation of the stars near the sun during\nthe total eclipse of the sun, May 29, 1919. The observed displacement\nof the apparent position of the stars is both quantitatively and\nqualitatively exactly as prophesied by Einstein. Again there should\nbe a perceptible lengthening of the time of oscillation of light in a\nvery strong gravitational field. This was not confirmed when Schlick\nwrote in January 1920, but has since been confirmed according to the\n_Scientific American_ for November 27, 1920, page 541.\n\n  NOTE: References by pages are to Schlick’s _Space and Time\n  in Contemporary Physics_.\n\n\n               OUTLINE OF AND COMMENTS ON SCHLICK’S BOOK.\n\n  Introduction. To be read before and after.\n\n  Chapter\n\n  I. General and of interest to any one.\n\n  II. Special Theory of Relativity. Essential to argument.\n\n  III. Geometrical Relativity of Space. Clear and easy for the\n  non-mathematician. Mathematician may omit.\n\n  IV. Mathematical Formulation of Spacial Relativity. Presentation\n  non-technical. Explains to the non-scientist why sometimes a\n  mathematician uses one geometry, sometimes another.\n\n  V. Inseparability of Geometry and Physics in Experience. Appeals\n  primarily to the philosophical reader.\n\n  VI. Relativity of Motion and its Connection with Inertia and\n  Gravitation. Essential to argument. Principle of equivalence and of\n  general relativity stated.\n\n  VII. General Postulate of Relativity. Essential to argument. More\n  difficult to read. Simple mathematics used.\n\n  VIII. Fundamental Law of the New Theory. Essential to argument.\n  Mathematical formulæ can easily be omitted. Contains statement of one\n  mathematical and two experimental verifications.\n\n  IX. Finitude of the Universe. Interesting to those who enjoy\n  speculations about the universe.\n\n  X. Relations to Philosophy. Of interest to the psychologist and\n  philosopher.\n\n\n\n\n                            Transformations\n\n\nONE sunshiny day last spring my friend and I sat talking in her office,\nthe office of a children’s home of which she was the head. A child came\nin to get a nickel to buy a tablet. My friend, finding no change in the\ncash drawer, had started to go upstairs after a nickel when I recalled\nher by offering her one. She accepted it with thanks, saying she would\nget one for me as soon as we went upstairs. To her suggestion I merely\nreplied: “Please don’t bother. It is of no moment.”\n\nTwo hours later I was sitting in the sun on the windswept platform of\nthe interurban. Suddenly I was aroused from my absorbing plans for the\nnext day’s lecture by a note of panic in a girl’s voice, rough and\nstrident though the voice itself was. “Say, could ya lend me two cents?\nI’ve lost my ticket, and I ain’t got quite enough to git home, and\nit’s several miles down the line.” “Sure,” I said, and fished out the\npennies. As they changed hands, she asked for my address so that she\nmight return them to me. “Oh, that’s all right. Forget it,” I said, and\nwe parted.\n\nThe thought which I had expressed was the same in both cases--the\ndesire to be of service, on my part, and the disparagement of the\nservice--but I had transformed the thought so that my very dignified\nfriend and the rough working girl would equally well understand it.\n\nA transformation, like all other fundamental mathematical processes,\nis, as Keyser suggests, a name for a process carried out with\nfinesse in mathematics, but used in a crude fashion throughout life.\nA dictionary affords countless illustrations of this process. The\ntelephone directory is a more precise transformation, for in it each\nnumber corresponds definitely to one house. Even in this illustration,\nhowever, notice that the correspondence is not usually a one-to-one\ncorrespondence, but a one-to-several correspondence.\n\nSometimes a transformation is so simple a thing as a change in the\nunit of measurement. Early in school one learns that four pecks equal\none bushel; four quarters equal one dollar. And by means of this\ntransformation one finds that sixteen pecks equal four bushels; sixteen\nquarters equal four dollars. Again, one inch on a map corresponds to\none hundred miles on the earth’s surface. Each of these is a concrete\nexample of the general type (1) x' = kx, when x' is measured in one\nunit, and x in a second, and when k is the constant ratio of the two\nunits.\n\nNow, instead of using x', introduce y. Then (1) becomes (1ʹ) y = kx,\na type of equation readily interpreted by freshmen as the equation\nrepresenting all the straight lines passing through the origin, if x\nand y are considered the co-ordinates of a point in plane analytical\ngeometry. Analytical geometry, a whole subject, may, then, be viewed as\na special kind of transformation.\n\nIn the field of analytical geometry, however, transformations appear\nmore fundamentally and more explicitly than indicated above. Let us\nconsider the assumptions upon which that scientific subject rests.\nThey are as follows:\n\n  (a) Two intersecting straight lines are assumed to exist. These are\n  called axes. The point of their intersection is called the origin.\n\n  (b) A unit on each axis is assumed, usually the same unit on each\n  axis but not necessarily so.\n\n  (c) On each axis directions are assigned arbitrarily as positive and\n  negative.\n\n  (d) A one-to-one correspondence is assumed to exist between the\n  points of each axis and the members of the real number system.\n\nIn accordance with an idea suggested by Keyser, to the effect that a\ntransformation is a psychological process of directing the attention\nfrom one object to another, it is found that the assumptions are in\nthemselves transformations; that the fourth assumption stated above is\nin fact a very precise transformation.\n\nIn analytical geometry, however, there is an even more explicit use\nof the transformation, frequently introduced for the purpose of\nsimplifying a discussion.\n\n[Illustration]\n\nSuppose the co-ordinate scheme having OX and OY as axes has been chosen\nin accordance with the form of the fundamental assumptions. Then a\npoint P is x units from the Y axis, and y units from the X axis; the\npoint O' is three units from the Y axis, and two units from the X\naxis. Since the axes are arbitrarily chosen, the point P would not be\nessentially altered if we located it by measuring its distances from\nO'X' and O'Y', lines parallel to OX and OY, instead of by its distances\nfrom OX and OY. But its distance from OY', which we shall call X',\nequals x - 3; and its distance from OX', which we shall call Y', equals\ny - 2. In fact, any point referred to in the old scheme is named in\nthe new scheme by substituting x - 3 and y - 2 respectively for its\nold co-ordinates. The point is not altered. Its name is altered. The\nrelationship\n\n(2) x' = x - 3\n    y' = y - 2\n\nis a special form of transformation called a translation. It amounts to\ngiving every point an alias, and to relating one set of assumptions to\nanother.\n\n[Illustration]\n\nIf, however, we had thought of the plane being shifted while the axes\nremained fixed, we should have had this state of affairs: P would have\nbeen moved two units down, and three to the left. Its new position\nwould have to the old the relationship indicated by (2), as before.\nThis amounts to giving every point an alibi.\n\nWith either interpretation it can be shown that certain geometrical\nproperties are unaltered by such a transformation, that is, a circle\nremains a circle, an ellipse an ellipse. Even if a translation is\ncombined with a change of scale,\n\n(3) x' = 5(x - 3)\n    y' = 6(y - 2),\n\nsome properties are not altered, such as the intersection of two\ncurves. Equations [such as (3)] are merely special cases of\n\n(4) x' = c_{1}(x - h)\n    y' = c_{2}(y - k),\n\na transformation which can be shown to leave unaltered many such\nproperties as those mentioned. Properties thus unaltered are said to\nbe invariant under transformation. For instance it can be shown that\nunder any translation a circle remains a circle, an ellipse an ellipse,\nintersections of curves are preserved, et cetera. Now, when the origin\nof the co-ordinate system is assumed to be in coincidence with the\ncenter of a circle, the equation of the circle has the simple form\n\nx^2 + y^2 = r^2,\n\nwhile when that assumption is not made, the equation is\n\nx^2 + 2ax + y^2 + 2by = r^2 - a^2 - b^2,\n\na much more complicated equation. Since, however, theorems proved\nfor one form have a corresponding statement for the other, we will\nnaturally use the simpler form to be secured by applying a translation\nwhich will place the origin at the center of the circle.\n\nThe confusion of tongues at the building of the tower of Babel, and the\ngiving of understanding on the day of Pentecost have always seemed to\nme to show the logical extremes of no transformation and of a perfect\ntransformation in the use of language to convey thought, itself an\ninvariant.\n\nThe modern study of invariants in mathematics has led to a knowledge of\nthe behavior of curves and functions so much deeper and broader than\nthat open to earlier generations that one is awed by the greatness\nof the concepts developed. But when one looks at the meagre study of\ninvariants in human conduct, one is tempted to agree with Korzybski\nthat humanity is only in its childhood, or even in its infancy. How\nmany of you really do recognize the same emotion in the expression of\na swearing, dirty, scrub-woman as she slams a hot dish on the table\n(long ago cleared of the supper things) before her husband, who is\nengaged in some such dangerous occupation as that of a lineman; and in\nthe expression of a well-dressed, prominent club-woman, as she presses\nher bridge-building husband into a seat at the table (cleared of the\ndinner dishes several hours ago) and pushes the button to summon the\nbutler? Poets sometimes call our attention to some of the invariants\nand the transformations by which one may pass from one to the other, as\nKipling, in _The Ladies_: “For the colonel’s lady and Judy O’Grady\nare sisters under their skins!” The historian is more scientific, and\npoints out that a government conducted by the mentally unfit falls.\nThis transformation has many concrete illustrations both in public and\nin national life. Yet there is no law in the United States to secure\nthe removal from the office of president of a man who becomes unfit\nmentally during his term. You decide to make friends with a girl, and\ndo not once determine whether or not those qualities which she displays\nunder “translation” or “rotation” are those which you understand and\nfind agreeable, or whether those qualities of hers which attract you\nare hers only when she is centrally located, that is, so located that\nthose qualities of hers which are agreeable to you are most readily\nperceived.\n\nWhen the mathematician points to the law of the multiplication of the\ndegenerates, and to the evils arising therefrom, the people reply by\nmaking a translation, which in no way affects that ability to multiply;\nthat is, they proclaim against birth-control by law.\n\nIn résumé, then, we may say that transformations are performed by\nus willy-nilly every time we think, every time we speak, every\ntime we listen to one another. Whether or not we know the laws of\ntransformations, we fulfill them just as truly as we fulfill the law\nof gravitation. Knowledge of these laws of transformations enables us\nto think more correctly, and hence to act more accurately. Thus bitter\nexperiences in misunderstandings between friends, and in maladjustments\nto society, are diminished in proportion to our knowledge. We have\nalso learned that a transformation can be viewed as a functional\nrelationship, that it is frequently interpretable as a functional\nrelationship called causal.\n\nInfinite possibilities appear to the thoughtful student of\ntransformations. But one more use of transformations it seems\nimpossible to omit, those of the type which directs the mind from the\ncontemplation of the finite to that of the infinite. An illustration\nfrom geometry will serve to symbolize the idea. Let AB and CD be two\nlimited line segments such that AB > CD.\n\n[Illustration]\n\nLet O be the intersection of AC and BD. Then we have the transformation\nthat to every point on AB there corresponds a point on CD obtained\nby joining that point on AB to O, and finding the intersection of the\nresulting line with CD, e. g. P_{2} ~ P_{1}. It is evident that to\nevery point on AB there corresponds a point on CD, and vice versa. Yet\nAB > CD, that is, a part seems to have become equal to the whole, a\nparadox indeed, reconcilable only by introducing explicitly a precise\nconcept of infinity: that the infinity of points in AB is an infinity\ncomparable to the infinity of points on CD, that is, that infinities\nmay be compared in magnitude, as are finite numbers. Thus we find the\nhuman mind conceiving of that which it may not represent concretely,\nand studying the laws governing those concepts.\n\n\n\n\n                “The Human Significance of Mathematics”\n\n  References:\n\n  _The Human Worth of Rigorous Thinking_, by Keyser; the two\n  essays “The Human Worth of Rigorous Thinking” and “The Human\n  Significance of Mathematics.”\n\n\nBERTRAND RUSSELL has given a definition of mathematics which is treated\nfacetiously by the ignorant, disparagingly by the superficial, and\nwith an almost awed consideration by the thoughtful. “Mathematics,”\nhe says, “is the science in which one never knows what one is talking\nabout, nor whether what one says is true.” (Keyser’s _Mathematical\nPhilosophy_, page 133.) You smile as I read it. The cause of the\nfacetiousness is obvious. In fact it is so tempting that no one wishes\nto miss it. Even when one stops smiling, it seems that a science so\ncharacterized is as far removed from having a human significance as any\nscience could possibly be.\n\nThat most practical, utilitarian subject, arithmetic, seems much more\nclosely allied to the human race. Its origin is almost contemporaneous\nwith that of speech, arising from so elemental a source as man’s\nneed to speak of more than one animal or enemy. Yet arithmetic is\napplied mathematics according to Russell. It is largely the result of\nexperience and has the lack of generality which characterizes any such\npurely experimental science.\n\nBut let us take an illustration; not however, from the beginnings of\ncivilization, but only as far back as the elementary school work in\nwhich you learned that:\n\n(1) 1 bushel = 4 pecks.\n\nThis represents an advanced stage of arithmetic, a change in the units\nof measurements, but it still has all the concreteness possible.\nYet see what imagination and logic have done. They have developed\ngeneralizations in arithmetic, generalizations now called the Theory of\nNumbers and Algebra. Algebra shows that (1) is merely a special case of\nall sets of numbers which have the ratio 4, and represents this by\n\n(2) y = 4x,\n\nwhere the units of measure are no longer stated. This is a true\nrelation in a great many concrete cases, for example, in\n\n$1.00 = 4 quarters.\n\nAnalytical geometry then makes a notable addition by disclosing\nthe fact that (2) not only has all the algebraic and arithmetical\ninterpretations previously suggested, but that it also may be used to\nrepresent a geometric concept, namely that of a straight line traced by\na moving point. It is, then, the logical form, of which all of those\ninterpretations which Russell calls mathematics are true.\n\nThen laws which may be proved true for this form, independent of its\ncontent, are true also for the special cases of this form, and will\nlikewise have an interpretation. A very simple example is this:\n\nIf   (2)  y = 4x,\nthen (3) 2y = 8x,\n\nno matter whether x be pecks and y equal bushels; or x, quarters and y,\ndollars; or x and y co-ordinates of a point: Cartesian geometry.\n\nAlthough now you see something serious, something not wholly facetious\nin Russell’s definition, even so the science seems a little thin,\nperhaps lacking in warmth and in the ability to inspire men to noble\nconceptions of life. Perhaps the obvious fields of applied mathematics\nwhich are the foundations of the engineering sciences,--trigonometry,\nanalytical geometry, and calculus,--seem to bind the subject more\nclosely to the lives of the individual. And assuredly they have a human\nvalue in that the appalling waste of human life and human energy as\nexemplified in the building of the pyramids no longer occurs, although\nmuch greater engineering feats--such as swinging Brooklyn Bridge, and\nburrowing under the Hudson River--are accomplished, and in much less\ntime.\n\nIs there, then, a still deeper human significance in Mathematics? For\nthese things according to Russell cannot be included. He would even\neliminate in his definition the geometric series by means of which we\ncan prophesy the number of children to be born in a given locality,\nprovided no earthquakes, et cetera, should occur (the probability\nof the occurrence of which event can also be determined). Even\napplications in art fail to be classified under his definition.\n\nLet us grant that such sciences and arts be excluded; yet we shall find\nin the residue of that great and ancient mass of knowledge usually\ndesignated “mathematics,” a significance more closely bound to human\nlife than that thus cast aside.\n\nGeneralizations have been made on these generalizations, and we have\ncalled them algebra and geometry. Great underlying principles have\nbeen discovered. Out of Descartes’ idea of thinking of a point moving\nso that it traces a curve, has developed a realization of variation,\nemphasized and augmented by the fluxions of Leibnitz and Newton, now\nknown as the calculus. In this day and generation variable and function\nare closely associated terms. A function is a variable which is known\nonly when the independent variable and the relationship between them\nis known. Here in the study of functions one meets a principle of such\nwide application that the existence of a field of human endeavor in\nwhich it does not hold is inconceivable. Let me illustrate, instead of\nstating, the principle. The area, _a_, of a rectangle, having the base,\n_b_, and altitude, _h_, is given by\n\n(3) A = b × h.\n\nIf _b_ equals six inches, and h equals two inches, then a equals twelve\nsquare inches. But if we are given only one value of the function, for\nexample, twelve square inches, how difficult it is to determine the\ndimensions of the rectangle! They might be any of the following:\n\n                                 1 × 12\n                                 2 × 6\n                                 3 × 4\n                                 5 × 12/5\n                                 6 × 2\n                                 7 × 12/7\n\nand so on ad infinitum. It is, therefore, not possible to know the\nindependent variables if only one value of the function is known and no\nfurther data is given.\n\nIt is, then, not possible to know a man’s motive if one sees but one\nact of a given type. A child brought up in a crowded street will, when\ngrown, still dodge the traffic downtown in Chicago without displaying\nany real bravery, while he who has grown up in the wilderness will\nexhibit commendable courage in crossing a street without waiting for\nthe signal of the traffic policeman.\n\nIf _a_ equals an act, remember that _b_ and _h_ can not only represent an\ninfinite number of motives, but can also admit of an infinite number of\nmisinterpretations.\n\nLet us suppose that the area of twelve square inches is the area of a\npaper sheet which is to fit into one of two note-books. The base and\nheight will at once be limited to a small range of numbers. If, in\naddition, we know that the paper is a common commercial product, we may\nbe able to determine those dimensions with exactitude.\n\nSimilarly if we have the framework into which to fit the lives of those\nindividuals whose motives we desire to learn from observation of their\nconduct, our guesses become increasingly accurate.\n\nLong ago Christ said, “Judge not, that ye be not judged.” This is an\nethical application of _A = b + h_. Now, when an idea reaches the point\nwhere it can be logically handled, man’s ability to use it, like his\nartistic appreciation of it, is increased. Mathematics shows that a\ngeneralization from a single instance, when the instance is a function\nand the generalization is the independent variable, is tommy-rot. You\nmay choose to regard it so or not. The results of your choice will\nfollow regardless. The choice may be a matter of free-will, but the\nresults are guaranteed by mathematics. Laws of thought can no more be\nviolated than can physical laws. They can only be fulfilled, precisely\nas the man who flies from the housetop fulfills the law of gravity as\nhe falls to the ground. “_Veritas_ vos liberabit.”\n\nGeneralization upon generalization has been made. Then, laws concerning\nthose forms themselves will be true for all the concrete illustrations\nof these forms. Have you a picture of all the concrete applications,\none by one uniting under abstractions, which in turn are united under\nfewer but more inclusive abstractions, all governed by laws? The laws\nare proved for these great abstract forms, and thus, far out along all\nthe lines of concreteness, flash interpretations known to be true.\n\nNow, a superficial thinker cannot conceive of form itself having\nlaws. But mathematicians are constantly studying the laws of the\nnon-representable.\n\nThought, that property characteristic of man, is, in the end, all that\ncan be truly said to exist.\n\nThat eternal change observed in every phenomenon of life (studied in\nmathematics under the name of variable) ever presses upon man, at\ntimes almost overwhelming him. Then man searches eagerly for something\nlasting, at rest (in contrast to in motion), purposeful--something to\nreconcile him to the continuous changes of this life. This quest is\nan ideal of thought, an ideal of rigor. Mathematics accomplishes\nwith finesse that towards which crude thought drifts; not always to\nperfection, of course, but in a degree ever approaching perfection as\na limit. “Mathematics is an ideal, a creation of the intellect in its\nquest for harmony.” (Keyser: _Human Worth of Rigorous Thinking_.)\nNay, it is even more. That lack of stability in life leads man to\nseek a resting place in thought, as the dove set free by Noah sought\na resting place far and wide over the surface of the tumbling waters.\nHere, then, we come to mathematics as defined by Keyser: “Transcending\nthe flux of the sensuous universe, there exists a stable world of pure\nthought, a divinely ordered world of ideas, accessible to men, free\nfrom the mad dance of time, infinite, and eternal.” Here, then, lies\nthe deepest law and inmost process of the universe of thought.\n\nFrom that most abstract of definitions we descend along the paths of\nutilitarianism, and ascend along the roads of art and philosophy, to\nthis most artistic of definitions. On the one peak stands Russell’s\ndefinition. (The content is unessential.) You have still to determine\nthe laws of the form, for as Keyser says, these things are eternal. On\nthe other hand stands Keyser’s definition. Bushels and pecks may go out\nof fashion. We may not know whether or not what we say is true, but\nwe have passed from the realm of sense to the realm of concept. Two\ndefinitions of mathematics, both involving a human significance as deep\nand as broad as life itself!\n\nFOOTNOTES:\n\n[Footnote 2: This paper was read before the meeting of the Illinois\nsection of the Mathematical Association, April 28, 1922.]\n\n[Footnote 3: Many have asked if it is possible to work up a “Browse”\ncourse while it is being given. It seems to me to be impossible if the\nlectures are to be well done. A year’s reading and listening to many\nlectures were needed to produce the two lectures on the Einstein Theory\nwhich were given so as to convey a real meaning to the class with only\nthe preparations mentioned in the paper. A superficial knowledge of any\nof the subjects presented in the courses would seem to me to be fatal\nto the scholarship of the course.\n\n--B. I. M.\n]\n\n\n\n\n                                Appendix\n\n                  Volume XV., November, 1922, Number 7\n\n                           ROMANCE IN SCIENCE\n\n    An Experimental Course Offered by a Department of Mathematics[2]\n\n                   By PROFESSOR BESSIE IRVING MILLER\n\n                            Rockford College\n\n\n=AT THE beginning of the second semester of this year we opened a\ntwo-hour course, popularly called “Browse,” with a description of\na sleek, cream-colored Jersey, standing in deep grass and pausing,\nafter a luscious bite, to gaze meditatively over the landscape. Before\nthe spring vacation, in that same course, I gave an examination on\nthe content of the Einstein Theory and its relation to the Newtonian\nTheory. Why, how, and with what results I made that transition are the\nsubjects of this paper.=\n\n=Two years ago at a section meeting of the Association, Dr. Slaught\nurged that, since we mathematicians had an interesting subject, we\nmight profitably take time occasionally to show the students how\ninteresting it was. This, combined with a previously observed fact that\nthe survey course of English literature not infrequently left the\nscience student with either a distaste for reading of any sort, or with\nthe expectation of usually being bored by it, galvanized me into making\nsome more definite observations, with the purpose of getting a solution\nfor the pedagogical problem presented.=\n\n=The results of these observations on my own classes are as follows:\nfirst, that a liking for reading can be aroused in the scientific\nstudent by references to scientific literature, not to text-books;\nsecond, that interest in scientific ideas can be aroused in the arts\nstudent by relating mathematics to other fields of knowledge through\nessays; third, that a greater lack of scientific literary background\nthan was usual in the preceding generation exists now among all types\nof students.=\n\n=With these results in mind I announced the new course under the\ndouble title “The Romance of Science or The Grammar of Science,\nWhichever You Wish,” to show the arts student that science had the\nimaginative quality which she so enjoyed, and to show the science\nstudent that poetry, fiction and opinions did not constitute the\nwhole of the world’s literature. In the college catalogue the course\nis described as being “Some Literature of Science,” a somewhat\ncommonplace title, which would not attract too much attention on the\npart of the ultra-conservatives in scientific teaching. “Browse” is\nthe unconventional nickname which was given the course because of\nits appropriateness to the purpose without having the unfortunate\nconnotation for the student that words such as “Meditate” might have,\nfor no American student is willing to acknowledge that she thinks, much\nless meditates.=\n\n=The prerequisite for the course is Freshman Mathematics or\nenrollment in that course with a grade of “B” for the first semester.\nThis secures some knowledge of analytical geometry, limits and\ndifferentiation on the part of all, although it is a very elementary\nknowledge.=\n\n=The main topics of the course are six in number. The first was the\nscientific method, ancient and modern. This was illustrated by the\nvarious theories of the earth’s motions, which led to Newton’s Law of\nGravitation, and which included a study of hypothesis and conclusion.\nThe second was dimensionality in algebra and geometry, including, of\ncourse, the fourth dimension; and the third, the distinction between\nEuclidean and Non-Euclidean geometries. These two involved a discussion\nof some popular fallacies and also of the scientist’s point of view,\nwhen he chooses the most convenient mathematical hypothesis from\nseveral, any one of which is equally logical. The fourth topic was the\nEinstein Theory, which involved no proof, but included a description\nof the theory and of its relation to the Newtonian Theory, a statement\nof the mathematical and experimental verifications up to date, and the\npresent status of the theory in the scientific field. The fifth topic,\nwhich I am now working on, is applications of mathematics in other\nfields than that of physics. This includes a discussion of the human\nvalue of mathematical thinking and the place held by mathematics in\ncivilization. The last subject will be some of the famous concepts of\nmathematics, such as number, limit, function, group.=\n\n=In addition to the main fields of investigation indicated above,\nside excursions into the domains of art, astronomy, biology, chemistry,\nmathematics, medicine and physics are made. This is possible because\nof the method of conducting the course. Once a week references and\nlectures are given on one of the main topics. Supplementary reading of\ntwo kinds is assigned over a considerable period of time. Each student\nchooses one long or two short books for her “browsing” throughout\nthe semester. She is guided only by her own taste except that her\nselection must be made from the official bibliography of the course.\nIn addition, essays or short books are so assigned that each student\nwill have read by the end of the semester one or more pieces of good\nliterature in each of five scientific fields not covered by her\n“browse” book. A second class appointment is devoted to discussions or\nspeeches or papers. The last two are sometimes expository and sometimes\ncritical.=\n\n=Some of the more obvious results of the course can be listed as\nfollows:=\n\n=1. An answer to the student’s query, “Why study mathematics?”=\n\n=2. An increased vocabulary for all and a remarkable improvement in\ncorrectness of speech and flow of language for the science student.=\n\n=3. A rebuttal of the statements, “Books Are Dull,” and “Science Is\nDull,” made by the science and arts students respectively.=\n\n=4. An extension of the intellectual horizon and a consequent\nincrease in intellectual tolerance.=\n\n=5. A knowledge of a scientific but literary reading list.=\n\n=6. A knowledge of some fundamental concepts of mathematics, the lack\nof which Henry Adams so bewails.=\n\n=7. A knowledge of some of the modern developments of mathematics.\nAfter further experimentation it is probable that a co-efficient can be\nattached to some of these results.=\n\n=The less obvious result aimed at by the course, which I cannot now\nmeasure and perhaps may never be able to measure, are a permanent taste\nfor reading and even more for “browsing.” The necessity of “browsing”\nis rather well expressed by Arnold Bennett in the last chapter of his\nlittle book called _Literary Taste and How to Form It_. I shall\nquote a little from this chapter called “Mental Stocktaking” in the\nhope that you will be lured on to read more. “The superlative cause\nof disastrous stocktaking remains. * * * It consists in the absence\nof meditation. * * * If a man does not spend at least as much time in\nactively and definitely thinking about what he has read as he has spent\nin reading, he is simply insulting his author. * * * Reading with him\nis a pleasant pastime and nothing else. This is a distressing fact. *\n* * It is distressing for the reason that meditation is not a popular\nexercise. If a friend asks you what you did last night, you may answer,\n‘I was reading,’ and he will be impressed and you will be proud. But\nif you answer, ‘I was meditating,’ he will have a tendency to smile and\nyou will have a tendency to blush. I know this. * * * (I cannot offer\nany explanation). But it does not shake my conviction that the absence\nof meditation is the main origin of disappointing stocktakings.” Most\nof us who teach will agree with Mr. Bennett.=\n\n=Although the results from the course have been very satisfactory,\nthere are some difficulties and dangers inherent in the very character\nof the course.[3] Depth may be sacrificed to breadth. Confusion may\nbe caused by the introduction of too many ideas, in which event it\nwould have one of the disadvantages of the literature course whose\neffect upon science students is so often to be deprecated. Idle\ndreaming may be cultivated instead of leisurely thinking. But it\nis not very difficult to avoid these dangers, and they are offset\nsomewhat by the flexibility of the course and its very general appeal,\nfor it can be given each year with variations, can be adapted to all\nclasses of students by means of the supplementary reading, can be\nused to eliminate popular fallacies concerning the study, content\nand applications of mathematics, and to stimulate interest in all\nthe sciences. It has certainly proved successful if the students’\ninterest, the extraordinary improvement shown by some, and the very\nhigh quality of work attained by others can be used as criteria.=\n\n=The reading list which follows contains not necessarily the best\nbooks which could be found anywhere, but the best which were accessible\nin our library this semester. Moreover, it does not aim to be\nexhaustive, but suggestive.=\n\n\n                      READING LIST FOR “BROWSING”\n\n                         In the Spring of 1922\n\n                Mathematics XVIII (speaking technically)\n\n\nASTRONOMY (A)\n\n  =1. _Astronomy._ Hinks. This is an elementary, non-technical\n  little book, written in a somewhat commonplace style and addressed to\n  any man.=\n\n  =2. _Origin of the Earth._ Chamberlain. This is well\n  written, presents interesting facts and theories, is trustworthy\n  scientifically and is addressed to an audience of intelligence having\n  little technical training. This was apparently the source of Prof.\n  Salisbury’s lecture last year.=\n\n  =3. _The Sun._ Sampson. This is one of the set of small,\n  scientific books, written in a good and interesting style, for\n  popular reading, where popular is used in the best sense of the\n  term. They require thinking, but not too much; they are printed very\n  clearly and are easy to hold. In fact their advantages are many,\n  but the shade of their binding, an unbelievable shade of pink, is\n  somewhat wearing.=\n\n  =4. _The Earth._ Poynting. This is another of the pink\n  series.=\n\n\nART AND MUSIC (AM)\n\n  =1. _Curves of Life._ Cook. This is a large, well illustrated\n  book giving illustrations of some mathematical curves, drawn from the\n  field of biology, art, etc. Much of it can be read by freshmen.=\n\n  =2. _Physical Basis of Music._ Wood. This is one of the\n  best of the pink series. There is little in it that is not very\n  enjoyable.=\n\n\nCHEMISTRY (C)\n\n  =1. _Creative Chemistry._ Slosson. This is so popularly\n  written that it gives incorrect scientific ideas by the assignment of\n  the powers to feel and to will to inanimate objects. The Egyptians of\n  the Pharaohs’ times would probably have approved of it. Its facts,\n  however, are trustworthy.=\n\n\nBIOLOGY (B)\n\n  =1. _Descent of Man._ Darwin. Darwin needs no introduction.\n  You might read it and find that he did not say what he is frequently\n  said to have said.=\n\n  =2. _Origin of Species._ Darwin. This proved to be very\n  delightful reading one summer, spent in the mountains. It served as\n  a transition from the writing of a mathematical dissertation to a\n  “Sherlock Holmes” story.=\n\n  =3. _Living Plants._ Ganong. Such an artistic piece of\n  scientific writing is rarely seen in these days of industrial\n  science, except in mathematics. Ganong’s book is as scholarly as it\n  is interesting, as clear in its style as in its type.=\n\n  =4. _Life of the Spider._ Fabre. I have not read it but know\n  it by reputation.=\n\n  =5. _Heredity._ Doncaster. This belongs to the pink series.=\n\n  =6. _Coming of Evolution._ Judd. This belongs to the pink\n  series.=\n\n  =7. _Harvard Classics No. 38._ Harvey, Jenner, Pasteur,\n  etc.=\n\n\nD\n\n=(This includes those books which are different or impossible to\nclassify.)=\n\n  =1. _Harvard Classics No. 30._ Physics, chemistry, astronomy,\n  geology. Faraday, Helmholtz, Kelvin, Newcomb, Geikie.=\n\n  =2. _Harvard Classics No. 33._ Physiology, medicine, surgery,\n  geology. Harvey, Jenner, Lister, Pasteur.=\n\n  =3. _Harvard Classics No. 29._ The Voyage of the Beagle.\n  Darwin.=\n\n  =4. _Discourses._ Biological and Geological Essays. Huxley.=\n\n  =5. _The Forest._ S. E. White. This is not scientific but it\n  is a well written description.=\n\n  =6. _Jungle Peace._ Beebe. This is a charming piece of writing\n  in the familiar essay style, and about such interesting things, that\n  one lingers in reading in order to prolong the pleasure.=\n\n  =7. _Science and the Nation._=\n\n  =8. _Realities of Modern Science._ Mills. The style is clear,\n  but commonplace. The facts presented are interesting and readily\n  understood. The book gives one quite a good idea of the scientific\n  method.=\n\n  =9. _Outlook for Research and Invention._ Hopkins.=\n\n  =10. _Grammar of Science._ Pearson. The first part is\n  interesting, the middle rather dull, the last part somewhat\n  interesting.=\n\n  =11. _Education of Henry Adams._=\n\n  =12. _Manhood of Humanity._ Korzybski.=\n\n\nGEOLOGY (G)\n\n  =1. _Earth Features._ Hobbs. This is addressed to a\n  nonspecialized intelligent reader. The illustrations are drawn from\n  the United States, especially the north and west.=\n\n  =2. _Physiography._ Salisbury. This is long but\n  interesting.=\n\n  =3. _Geology._ Lyell. This is old but interesting.=\n\n\nMATHEMATICS (M)\n\n  =1. _Flatland._ A Square. This small book is useful rather\n  than beautiful, but it is amusing and stimulating, if read with care\n  at the beginning, and glanced at casually towards the end. It is easy\n  to understand and yet gives the idea of dimension in space so that it\n  can be applied.=\n\n  =2. _John Napier and the Invention of Logarithms._ Hobson.\n  This is a half hour’s reading about an instrument all Rockford\n  graduates have used.=\n\n  =3. _Number System in Algebra._ Fine. This is interestingly\n  written and not hard to read. It deals with that familiar but little\n  understood thing called numbers and tells how they came to be.=\n\n  =4. _Study and Difficulties of Mathematics._ De Morgan. This\n  is pleasant reading. It is one of the books bound in red.=\n\n  =5. _Mathematical Recreations._ Ball. This is full of games\n  and puzzles as well as of other things. It is something of a scrap\n  book.=\n\n  =6. _Mathematical Essays._ Schubert. If you enjoy the somewhat\n  serious essay as a form of literature, you will probably enjoy some\n  of these.=\n\n  =7. _Memorabilia Mathematica._ Mortiz. If you want an epigram\n  or a definition, a topic for a paper or a proof of the diversities\n  of men’s ideas, read a few bits here and there. The book is a\n  collection of notable sayings and writings either by or about either\n  Mathematics or mathematicians.=\n\n  =8. _Human Worth of Rigorous Thinking._ Keyser. This is a\n  collection of essays and lectures. Numbers I-VIII, XIV, XV are of\n  general cultural value. The style is excellent and the ideas are\n  sometimes interesting and sometimes inspiring.=\n\n  =9. _Fundamental Concepts of Algebra and Geometry._ Young.\n  This is non-technical in that it assumes no knowledge of mathematics\n  beyond elementary high school algebra and geometry. It is a series of\n  lectures addressed to an audience interested in mathematics.=\n\n  =10. _Foundations of Geometry._ Hilbert. This is perhaps the\n  most polished expression and the most scholarly treatment of the\n  subject that has ever been written.=\n\n  =11. _Fundamental Concepts of Modern Mathematics._ Richardson\n  and Landis. This is one of the disappointments of this generation.\n  Its mathematics cannot be trusted.=\n\n  =12. _Philosophy of Mathematics._ Shaw.=\n\n  =13. _Space and Time._ Schick. This gives Einstein’s theory,\n  omitting the mathematical proofs.=\n\n  =14. _Organization of Thought._ Whitehead. This is more\n  interesting than 15 both in style and content. Chapters I, II, VI,\n  VII, VIII are perhaps the best. I read them with pleasure when\n  sitting in the lobby of the Auditorium Hotel, where one may while\n  away many an hour, musing over a book of this type and collecting\n  data on human nature. It is not a book to hurry through, yet it is\n  not so profound as to require one’s study for its perusal. Perhaps\n  this is because it consists of a series of lectures originally\n  addressed to an attentive audience but one which was enjoying a\n  vacation from routine duties. It is non-technical.=\n\n  =15. _Principles of Natural Knowledge._ Whitehead. This is\n  an “enquiry.” It has a most interesting origin you will find, if\n  you read the introduction. The book is concerned with theories of\n  the nature of matter, and the ultimate data of matter, the relation\n  of geometry to science, the effects of the theories of relativity.\n  If you think you know all about lines and points, read and be\n  disillusioned.=\n\n  =16. _Foundations of Science._ Poincaré. This requires\n  maturity of mind, not a specialist’s training. Remember it, so that\n  when you reach the point where much that you read seems commonplace,\n  because of its familiarity, and you really have the thrill of\n  coming in contact with a new idea or a new correlation of ideas,\n  where the beauty of the abstract seems greater than the beauty of\n  the concrete, then read Poincaré, leisurely, sometimes dreaming,\n  sometimes meditating, sometimes experimenting, but always thinking.\n  Then the simplicity of the language, the dignity of the concepts,\n  the inspirational suggestiveness of the thought may give you that\n  permanent acquisition, a moment in which you live nobly and below\n  which you may never sink as low as you have in the past. But beware,\n  lest having eyes, ye see not.=\n\n  =17. Science. March, 1912. _Organization of Knowledge._=\n\n  =18. _The Absolute Relations of Time & Space._ A. A. Robb.=\n\n  =19. _The Einstein Theory of Relativity._ Prof. H. A.\n  Lorentz.=\n\n\nPHYSICS (P)\n\n  =1. _Wireless Telegraphy._ Fortescue.=\n\n  =2. _The Atmosphere._ Berry.=\n\n  =3. _Beyond the Atom._ Cox. These three belong to the pink\n  series.=\n\n  =4. _Experimental Researches in Electricity._ Faraday. Notice\n  the motto used as the frontispiece.=\n\n  =5. _Soap Bubbles._ Boys.=\n\n  =6. _Light, Visible and Invisible._ Thompson. This has a\n  pleasing style, interesting contents and is easily understood.=\n\n  =7. _Surface Tension._ Willows and Hotschek.=\n\n  =8. _Electricity and Matter._ Thompson.=\n\n  =9. _The Electron._ Milliken.=\n\n  =10. _Sound._ Tyndall.=\n\n  =11. _Light._ Tyndall.=\n\n  =12. _The New Physics._ Poincaré.=\n\n  =13. _Visual Illusions & Their Applications._ Luckiesh.=\n\n  =14. _The Concept of Nature._ Whitehead.=\n\n\nPSYCHOLOGY (P3)\n\n  =1. _Mysticism, Freudianism and Scientific Psychology._\n  Dunlap.=\n\n\n                         =TRANSCRIBER’S NOTES=\n\nSimple typographical errors have been silently corrected.\n\nPunctuation, hyphenation, and spelling were made consistent when a\npredominant preference was found in the original book; otherwise they\nwere not changed.\n\n\n\n\n*** END OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK ROMANCE IN SCIENCE ***\n\n\n    \n\nUpdated editions will replace the previous one—the old editions will\nbe renamed.\n\nCreating the works from print editions not protected by U.S. copyright\nlaw means that no one owns a United States copyright in these works,\nso the Foundation (and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United\nStates without permission and without paying copyright\nroyalties. Special rules, set forth in the General Terms of Use part\nof this license, apply to copying and distributing Project\nGutenberg™ electronic works to protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG™\nconcept and trademark. Project Gutenberg is a registered trademark,\nand may not be used if you charge for an eBook, except by following\nthe terms of the trademark license, including paying royalties for use\nof the Project Gutenberg trademark. If you do not charge anything for\ncopies of this eBook, complying with the trademark license is very\neasy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose such as creation\nof derivative works, reports, performances and research. Project\nGutenberg eBooks may be modified and printed and given away—you may\ndo practically ANYTHING in the United States with eBooks not protected\nby U.S. copyright law. Redistribution is subject to the trademark\nlicense, especially commercial redistribution.\n\n\nSTART: FULL LICENSE\n\nTHE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG™ LICENSE\n\nPLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK\n\nTo protect the Project Gutenberg™ mission of promoting the free\ndistribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work\n(or any other work associated in any way with the phrase “Project\nGutenberg”), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full\nProject Gutenberg License available with this file or online at\nwww.gutenberg.org/license.\n\nSection 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg\nelectronic works\n\n1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg\nelectronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to\nand accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property\n(trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all\nthe terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or\ndestroy all copies of Project Gutenberg electronic works in your\npossession. If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a\nProject Gutenberg electronic work and you do not agree to be bound\nby the terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person\nor entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8.\n\n1.B. “Project Gutenberg” is a registered trademark. It may only be\nused on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who\nagree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few\nthings that you can do with most Project Gutenberg electronic works\neven without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See\nparagraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project\nGutenberg electronic works if you follow the terms of this\nagreement and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg\nelectronic works. See paragraph 1.E below.\n\n1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation (“the\nFoundation” or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection\nof Project Gutenberg electronic works. Nearly all the individual\nworks in the collection are in the public domain in the United\nStates. If an individual work is unprotected by copyright law in the\nUnited States and you are located in the United States, we do not\nclaim a right to prevent you from copying, distributing, performing,\ndisplaying or creating derivative works based on the work as long as\nall references to Project Gutenberg are removed. Of course, we hope\nthat you will support the Project Gutenberg mission of promoting\nfree access to electronic works by freely sharing Project Gutenberg\nworks in compliance with the terms of this agreement for keeping the\nProject Gutenberg name associated with the work. You can easily\ncomply with the terms of this agreement by keeping this work in the\nsame format with its attached full Project Gutenberg License when\nyou share it without charge with others.\n\n1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern\nwhat you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are\nin a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States,\ncheck the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this\nagreement before downloading, copying, displaying, performing,\ndistributing or creating derivative works based on this work or any\nother Project Gutenberg work. The Foundation makes no\nrepresentations concerning the copyright status of any work in any\ncountry other than the United States.\n\n1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg:\n\n1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other\nimmediate access to, the full Project Gutenberg License must appear\nprominently whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg work (any work\non which the phrase “Project Gutenberg” appears, or with which the\nphrase “Project Gutenberg” is associated) is accessed, displayed,\nperformed, viewed, copied or distributed:\n\n    This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most\n    other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions\n    whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms\n    of the Project Gutenberg™ License included with this eBook or online\n    at www.gutenberg.org. If you\n    are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws\n    of the country where you are located before using this eBook.\n  \n1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is\nderived from texts not protected by U.S. copyright law (does not\ncontain a notice indicating that it is posted with permission of the\ncopyright holder), the work can be copied and distributed to anyone in\nthe United States without paying any fees or charges. If you are\nredistributing or providing access to a work with the phrase “Project\nGutenberg” associated with or appearing on the work, you must comply\neither with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 or\nobtain permission for the use of the work and the Project Gutenberg\ntrademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.\n\n1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is posted\nwith the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution\nmust comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any\nadditional terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms\nwill be linked to the Project Gutenberg License for all works\nposted with the permission of the copyright holder found at the\nbeginning of this work.\n\n1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg\nLicense terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this\nwork or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg.\n\n1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this\nelectronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without\nprominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with\nactive links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project\nGutenberg License.\n\n1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary,\ncompressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including\nany word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access\nto or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg work in a format\nother than “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or other format used in the official\nversion posted on the official Project Gutenberg website\n(www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense\nto the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means\nof obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original “Plain\nVanilla ASCII” or other form. Any alternate format must include the\nfull Project Gutenberg License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1.\n\n1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying,\nperforming, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg works\nunless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.\n\n1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing\naccess to or distributing Project Gutenberg electronic works\nprovided that:\n\n    • You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from\n        the use of Project Gutenberg works calculated using the method\n        you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is owed\n        to the owner of the Project Gutenberg trademark, but he has\n        agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the Project\n        Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments must be paid\n        within 60 days following each date on which you prepare (or are\n        legally required to prepare) your periodic tax returns. Royalty\n        payments should be clearly marked as such and sent to the Project\n        Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the address specified in\n        Section 4, “Information about donations to the Project Gutenberg\n        Literary Archive Foundation.”\n    \n    • You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies\n        you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he\n        does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg™\n        License. You must require such a user to return or destroy all\n        copies of the works possessed in a physical medium and discontinue\n        all use of and all access to other copies of Project Gutenberg™\n        works.\n    \n    • You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of\n        any money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the\n        electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days of\n        receipt of the work.\n    \n    • You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free\n        distribution of Project Gutenberg™ works.\n    \n\n1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project\nGutenberg™ electronic work or group of works on different terms than\nare set forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing\nfrom the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the manager of\nthe Project Gutenberg™ trademark. Contact the Foundation as set\nforth in Section 3 below.\n\n1.F.\n\n1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable\neffort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread\nworks not protected by U.S. copyright law in creating the Project\nGutenberg™ collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg™\nelectronic works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may\ncontain “Defects,” such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate\nor corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other\nintellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or\nother medium, a computer virus, or computer codes that damage or\ncannot be read by your equipment.\n\n1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the “Right\nof Replacement or Refund” described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project\nGutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project\nGutenberg™ trademark, and any other party distributing a Project\nGutenberg™ electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all\nliability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal\nfees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT\nLIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE\nPROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE\nTRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE\nLIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR\nINCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH\nDAMAGE.\n\n1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a\ndefect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can\nreceive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a\nwritten explanation to the person you received the work from. If you\nreceived the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium\nwith your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you\nwith the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in\nlieu of a refund. If you received the work electronically, the person\nor entity providing it to you may choose to give you a second\nopportunity to receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If\nthe second copy is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing\nwithout further opportunities to fix the problem.\n\n1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth\nin paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you ‘AS-IS’, WITH NO\nOTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT\nLIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE.\n\n1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied\nwarranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of\ndamages. If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement\nviolates the law of the state applicable to this agreement, the\nagreement shall be interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or\nlimitation permitted by the applicable state law. The invalidity or\nunenforceability of any provision of this agreement shall not void the\nremaining provisions.\n\n1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the\ntrademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone\nproviding copies of Project Gutenberg™ electronic works in\naccordance with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the\nproduction, promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg™\nelectronic works, harmless from all liability, costs and expenses,\nincluding legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of\nthe following which you do or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this\nor any Project Gutenberg work, (b) alteration, modification, or\nadditions or deletions to any Project Gutenberg work, and (c) any\nDefect you cause.\n\nSection 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg\n\nProject Gutenberg is synonymous with the free distribution of\nelectronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of\ncomputers including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It\nexists because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations\nfrom people in all walks of life.\n\nVolunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the\nassistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg’s\ngoals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg collection will\nremain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project\nGutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure\nand permanent future for Project Gutenberg and future\ngenerations. To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary\nArchive Foundation and how your efforts and donations can help, see\nSections 3 and 4 and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org.\n\nSection 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation\n\nThe Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non-profit\n501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the\nstate of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal\nRevenue Service. The Foundation’s EIN or federal tax identification\nnumber is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg Literary\nArchive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent permitted by\nU.S. federal laws and your state’s laws.\n\nThe Foundation’s business office is located at 41 Watchung Plaza #516,\nMontclair NJ 07042, USA, +1 (862) 621-9288. Email contact links and up\nto date contact information can be found at the Foundation’s website\nand official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact\n\nSection 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg\nLiterary Archive Foundation\n\nProject Gutenberg™ depends upon and cannot survive without widespread\npublic support and donations to carry out its mission of\nincreasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be\nfreely distributed in machine-readable form accessible by the widest\narray of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations\n($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt\nstatus with the IRS.\n\nThe Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating\ncharities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United\nStates. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a\nconsiderable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up\nwith these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations\nwhere we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To SEND\nDONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any particular state\nvisit www.gutenberg.org/donate.\n\nWhile we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we\nhave not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition\nagainst accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who\napproach us with offers to donate.\n\nInternational donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make\nany statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from\noutside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff.\n\nPlease check the Project Gutenberg web pages for current donation\nmethods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other\nways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. To\ndonate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate.\n\nSection 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg electronic works\n\nProfessor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project\nGutenberg concept of a library of electronic works that could be\nfreely shared with anyone. For forty years, he produced and\ndistributed Project Gutenberg eBooks with only a loose network of\nvolunteer support.\n\nProject Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed\neditions, all of which are confirmed as not protected by copyright in\nthe U.S. unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not\nnecessarily keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper\nedition.\n\nMost people start at our website which has the main PG search\nfacility: www.gutenberg.org.\n\nThis website includes information about Project Gutenberg,\nincluding how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary\nArchive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to\nsubscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks.\n\n\n","snippet":"","snippet_marked":"","source":"Project Gutenberg","citation":"https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/79853","license":"Public domain (per item)","year":"","url":"/record/79853","fields":{"author":"Bessie Irving Miller","language":"English","chars":"117872","source_url":"https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/79853"}},"generated_at":"2026-11-22T20:37:50Z"}